Alternatives to Classic All Butter Mince Pies

How alternatives were chosen: Based on products in the same category that have nutrition facts, ordered by sugars, lowest first (values per 100 g; ties by name). The list does not drop products with a higher value than the original; the differences are shown next to each product · check the label.

120 alternatives, ordered by sugars, lowest first

1. 1
   Greggs Steak Bake (in-store) −94 calories+6.2 g protein−0.2 g sat. fat−39.5 g sugars
   300Calories 10Protein 19Fat 9.3Sat. fat 0Sugars Compare Alternatives
2. 2
   Port Royal Mutton Pie −111 calories+4.8 g protein−3.9 g sat. fat−39.0 g sugars
   283Calories 8.6Protein 18Fat 5.6Sat. fat 0.5Sugars Compare Alternatives
3. 3
   Upper Crust Chicken & Asparagus Pie −124 calories+5.5 g protein−3 g sat. fat−38.9 g sugars
   270Calories 9.3Protein 14Fat 6.5Sat. fat 0.6Sugars Compare Alternatives
4. 4
   Pieminister Free range chicken & ham pie −167 calories+5.9 g protein−3.6 g sat. fat−38.9 g sugars
   227Calories 9.7Protein 11.3Fat 5.9Sat. fat 0.6Sugars Compare Alternatives
5. 5
   Greenhalgh's Potato & Meat Pies −172 calories+1.8 g protein−5.1 g sat. fat−38.8 g sugars
   222Calories 5.6Protein 10.5Fat 4.4Sat. fat 0.7Sugars Compare Alternatives
6. 6
   Sainsbury’s Free from Steak & Gravy Pie −130 calories+4.1 g protein−3 g sat. fat−38.8 g sugars
   264Calories 7.9Protein 11.4Fat 6.5Sat. fat 0.7Sugars Compare Alternatives
7. 7
   Sainsbury's chicken & gravy shortcrust pastry pie 500g −138 calories+5.4 g protein−5.3 g sat. fat−38.7 g sugars
   256Calories 9.2Protein 12.6Fat 4.2Sat. fat 0.8Sugars Compare Alternatives
8. 8
   Ginsters Creamy Garlic Mushroom slice −163 calories+0.2 g protein−1.9 g sat. fat−38.7 g sugars
   231Calories 4Protein 15Fat 7.6Sat. fat 0.8Sugars Compare Alternatives
9. 9
   Marks & Spencer M&S -FOOD- Gastro Cotta Milk Celery gastropub INGR −253 calories+6.3 g protein−6.3 g sat. fat−38.7 g sugars
   141Calories 10.1Protein 6.9Fat 3.2Sat. fat 0.8Sugars Compare Alternatives
10. 10
    Beef shin, smoked bacon and ale pie −321 calories+4.7 g protein−1.3 g sat. fat−38.6 g sugars
    72.7Calories 8.5Protein 18Fat 8.2Sat. fat 0.9Sugars Compare Alternatives
11. 11
    Clive's Classic Pie Mushroom −123 calories−0.2 g protein−1.3 g sat. fat−38.6 g sugars
    271Calories 3.6Protein 16.9Fat 8.2Sat. fat 0.9Sugars Compare Alternatives
12. 12
    Cottage pie −258 calories+2 g protein−6.9 g sat. fat−38.6 g sugars
    136Calories 5.8Protein 6.2Fat 2.6Sat. fat 0.9Sugars Compare Alternatives
13. 13
    Marks & Spencer Creamy garlic mushroom puff pastry pie −143 calories+0.3 g protein−2.5 g sat. fat−38.6 g sugars
    251Calories 4.1Protein 15.3Fat 7Sat. fat 0.9Sugars Compare Alternatives
14. 14
    Higgidy Steak & Red wine pie −161 calories+6.9 g protein−2.8 g sat. fat−38.6 g sugars
    233Calories 10.7Protein 12.7Fat 6.7Sat. fat 0.9Sugars Compare Alternatives
15. 15
    Waitrose Chicken Gravy Pie −133 calories+4.8 g protein−3.5 g sat. fat−38.5 g sugars
    261Calories 8.6Protein 15.2Fat 6Sat. fat 1Sugars Compare Alternatives
16. 16
    Pieminister Evergreen −192 calories+1.5 g protein−38.5 g sugars
    202Calories 5.3Protein 11.1Fat —Sat. fat 1Sugars Compare Alternatives
17. 17
    Higgidy Slow Cooked Steak Red Wine And Bacon Pie −174 calories+6.1 g protein−4.2 g sat. fat−38.5 g sugars
    220Calories 9.9Protein 10Fat 5.3Sat. fat 1Sugars Compare Alternatives
18. 18
    Pukka Steak & Kidney Pie −169 calories+5.9 g protein−4.8 g sat. fat−38.5 g sugars
    225Calories 9.7Protein 11.8Fat 4.7Sat. fat 1Sugars Compare Alternatives
19. 19
    M&S Food Deep Filled Steak Shortcrust Pastry Pie −114 calories+6.1 g protein−1.9 g sat. fat−38.4 g sugars
    280Calories 9.9Protein 15.5Fat 7.6Sat. fat 1.1Sugars Compare Alternatives
20. 20
    Pukka All Steak pie −164 calories+5.0 g protein−2.9 g sat. fat−38.4 g sugars
    230Calories 8.8Protein 12.6Fat 6.6Sat. fat 1.1Sugars Compare Alternatives
21. 21
    Gastropub Cottage pie −263 calories+6.0 g protein−5.4 g sat. fat−38.4 g sugars
    131Calories 9.8Protein 6Fat 4.1Sat. fat 1.1Sugars Compare Alternatives
22. 22
    M&S Food Mini Meal Fish Pie −312 calories+2.2 g protein−8.4 g sat. fat−38.4 g sugars
    82Calories 6Protein 2.1Fat 1.1Sat. fat 1.1Sugars Compare Alternatives
23. 23
    Lidl Salmon Wellington with Creamy Prawn & White Wine Sauce −168 calories+6.2 g protein−4.2 g sat. fat−38.4 g sugars
    226Calories 10Protein 13.3Fat 5.3Sat. fat 1.1Sugars Compare Alternatives
24. 24
    Higgidy Spinach, Feta & Toasted Pine Nut Pie −136 calories+5.4 g protein−2.3 g sat. fat−38.4 g sugars
    258Calories 9.2Protein 17.9Fat 7.2Sat. fat 1.1Sugars Compare Alternatives

Back to Classic All Butter Mince Pies